Oral Argument Summaries - May 2009

This post contains oral argument summaries from the Federal Circuit's May 2009 sitting.  I listen to the arguments on planes or in my car, and I do not write the summaries until later, so please use these summaries only for issue spotting, and check the actual MP3's if you want complete accuracy.

2008-1415  ITC  NORGREN INC v ITC (Schall Gajarsa Moore) 05-04-09 (1 of 5 stars)
This is a claim construction case involving a clamp that receives a flange.  The main question is whether the flange has to be wholly within te clamp.  A second questin is whether a "generally rectangular ported flange" requires four separate tabs to extend outward from a central rectangular hub or whether only two are sufficient.  In other words the question seems to be whether the rectangular flange is the entire structure or only the parts of the structure that stick outward.

2008-1456  DCT  HEALTHPORT CORP v TANITA CORP (Schall Gajarsa Moore) 05-04-09 (1 of 5 stars)
The district court had granted summary judgment of noninfringement and the patentee argues (1) the court had imported a limitation into the claims and (2) misidentified corresponding structure for a « means » limitation.  On the former the patent indicates that it is important that a patient not move when being measured by the invention so the district court read such a limitation into the claim.  The patentee emphasizes that the claim is an apparatus claim so reading such a limitation into the claim is particularly wrong.  On the latter the patentee argues that the structure for a « mounting means for removably attaching» should include a computer in the patent.  The defendant cross-appeals to get its fees for a frivolous case.  This appeal suffered a Rule 36 affirmance. 

2008-1468  DCT  UNIV OF PITTSBURGH v HEDRICK  (Mayer Rader Bryson) ) 05-04-09 (2 of 5 stars)
This case asks the court to draw the line between a hypothesis and a real conception.  The invention relates to stem cells and the appellant asserts that the conception did not occur until the inventors actually found a particular cell in their test sample.  The appellee asserts that any lack of certainty in the inventors’ records simply shows pragmatic scientific caution.  One problem for the appellee is that the patent lists a co-inventor who was not even around on the alleged date of conception.

2008-1498  DCT  SOFPOOL v INTEX RECREATION (Mayer Friedman Rader) 05-05-09 (1 of 5 stars)
This is a design patent case that was tried before Egyptian Goddess and the panel thus seems inclined to send the case back for a new trial.  It seems there might be a question of whether the appellant waived the issue but that issue is not pushed very much.  The appellee argues that the instructions were substantially correct when read as a whole.  This case was quickly vacated in a non-precedential opinion.

2008-1500  DCT  ANASCAPE v MICROSOFT (Newman Gajarsa Dyk) 05-05-09 (2 of 5 stars)
This case might ask what happens when incorporated material is inconsistent with the specification of the patent-in-suit.  The invention here is a multi-axis motion-controlled game controller and the question is whether the incoporated material includes a disclaimer and thus acts to limit the invention to a controller that uses a single input mechanism.  Much of the argument centered on what was disclosed by particular figures in the patent-in-suit.  Separately there is an issue of whether the damages award makes any sense or is simply a compromise verdict.  Bill Lee from Hale & Dorr represents appellant Nintendo (Microsoft must have settled out or deferred in the argument). 

2008-1509  DCT  BD TRUSTEE LELAND v ROCHE (Linn Prost Moore) 05-05-09 (1 of 5 stars)
The district court granted summary judgment of obviousness.  The appellant argues that the court made serious fact findings on issues such as predictability and the level of skill in the art.  There is also a major question here about whether the assignment from the inventors violated Bayh-Dole and the practical result if it did.

2008-1554  DCT  FARRAGO v RAWLINGS SPORTING (Mayer Lourie Gajarsa) 05-06-09 (1 of 5 stars)
This is a claim construction case relating to a athletic leg support.  The patent requires a shape having four surfaces as opposed to a prior art less comfortable triangular shape.  The question appears to be whether a continuoius curve can define two distinct surfaces or must be a single surface (which I presume drives the question of whether the defendant has 3 or 4 surfaces).  This appeal suffered a Rule 36 affirmance.

2008-1589  DCT  BIOLUMIX v CENTRUS INTL (Rader Linn Prost) 05-06-09 (1 of 5 stars)
The issue in this case is whether a patent assignment is subject to an arbitration clause.  The issues sound pretty case-specific.  There was an alter ego finding by the district court without discovery.  This appeal suffered a Rule 36 affirmance.

2008-1448  PTO  IN RE BOSE CORP (Michel Dyk Moore) 05-06-09 (3 of 5 stars)
This is an interesting appeal.  A trademark applicant in an apparent misunderstanding of the law signed a declaration that a mark was being used in interstate commerce when no products had been sold with the mark in several years but the applicant was making repairs to the goods.  The Board said the person knew or should have known his reading of the law was wrong so it found the registration unenforceable.  There is extensive discussion about whether the Fed Cir’s mention of « knew or sould have known » in its prior Torres decision required the panel to affirm (or go en banc).  Judge Moore pointed to a decision by then-Judge Alito in which he explained the « should have known » language does not excuse a court or Board from finding actual deceptive intent but instead was used by the court as a signal that it did not believe the witness on its way to finding that the witness had deceptive intent.

Chuck Heiken of Fish & Richardson represented Bose.

2009-1023  DCT  AMGEN v ARIAD PHARMACEUTICALS  (Michel Dyk Moore) 05-06-09 (3 of 5 stars)
This is a claim construction case where the claim says « in the cell » and the question is where that is and what must occur there.  A lot of the discussion was case-specific biotechie stuff.

Evan Chesler of Cravath represented the appellant and he’s pretty good.

2009-1029  PTO  IN RE BAGGETT (Gajarsa Plager Linn) 05-07-09 (1 of 5 stars)
This was an appeal from the rejection of claims that are directed to making determinations for the pricing of airfares in a manner that is computationally efficient.  There was discussion about what the prior art actually disclosed.  Notes:  Baggett was represented by Dennis Maloney of Fish & Richardson.  The argument started with the admission of two of Judge Gajarsa’s law clerks.

2009-1019  DCT  NETCURRENTS INFO v DOW JONES  (Gajarsa Plager Linn) 05-07-09 (1 of 5 stars)
This is a claim construction case in which the claims require updating of certain information in real-time and the question is whether daily updates can be considered to be real-time.  The district court had granted summary judgment of noninfringement.  Netcurrents asserts that was infringement (or at least a fact issue) even under the district court’s construction and that the district court erred in accepting allegedly inconsistent and conclusory testimony from Dow Jones’ witnesses.  This appeal suffered a Rule 36 affirmance. 

2008-1544  PTO  IN RE REIFFIN  (Mayer Bryson Prost) 05-07-09 (1 of 5 stars)
The appellant in this reexamination argues that the Board acted ultra vires by considering questions of patentability that were not new—i.e. the effective filing date which he says was implicitly considered by the prior examiner apparently.  He also makes a claim construction argument regarding whether two components had to be part of a single unit (an issue he accuses the solicitor of running away from).  The argument sounded very fact-specific—though interestingly the patent application was filed 27 years ago (and I presume this related to the Reiffen v. Microsoft litigation though I do not know that).

2009-1045  DCT  WEDGETAIL v HUDDLESTON DELUXE (Schall Gajarsa Dyk) 05-08-09 (1 of 5 stars)
Appellant argues that it was denied procedural due processvia an opportunity to move for attorney fees and costs.  Apparently the judge simply made a statement in court that led the appellant to believe it could not move on the issues.  This case may have ben affected by the Supreme Court’s recent Shinsecky ruling that requires a party to show harmful error from being denied such an opportunity.

2009-1047  DCT  GARBER v CHICAGO MERCANTILE EXCH (Michel Lourie Prost) 05-08-09 (1 of 5 stars)
This is a case concerning the interpretation of a Rule 41 stipulation.  The actual facts were not too clear to me though the appellant argues that the district court erred in discerning the parties’ intent.  The case may turn on whether Ruloe 41(a)(1) for stipulated dismissals is self-executing (the appellant’s position) or instead requires some sort of intervening judicial action.  The appellee instead argues that the agreement falls under Rule 41(a)(2) -- even though it was called a « stpiulation «  -- because it contained a condition.

 

Comments

[Alyssa_Arizona]

I hate to see us lose your input but I wonder if simply publishing articles with no comments enabled and having a members-only forum wouldn't be a good compromise. There's something about the immediacy of the response form and the lack of accountability available from anonymity (oh, hypocritical me) that seems to encourage people's awfulness., http://dakotafanningnakeddg.tumblr.com dakota fanning naked, elp, http://selenagomeznudefakesvv.tumblr.com selena gomez nude fakes, 1454, http://demilovatoassgi.tumblr.com demi lovato ass, 95801, http://sarahroemernudebb.tumblr.com sarah roemer nude, 296858, http://vidaguerrapornss.tumblr.com vida guerra porn, >:-(, http://gwynethpaltrowsexhc.tumblr.com gwyneth paltrow sex, 860, http://alessandraambrosionudehn.tumblr.com alessandra ambrosio nude, 8],

[Kaitlyn_Alabama]

It's entirely possible that I copied that individual number across incorrectly (and that the index was correct), but when I did the query just then it returned a Technorati Rank of 37, so as you say there would be no change in the rank, but an improvement in your index., http://katrinakaifboobsps.tumblr.com katrina kaif boobs, hdgo, http://candicemichellenakedwr.tumblr.com candice michelle naked, 73303, http://zacefronnupy.tumblr.com zac efron nu, :-[[, http://kristenstewartnakedvg.tumblr.com kristen stewart naked, wtx, http://ashleytisdalesexymr.tumblr.com ashley tisdale sexy, ghk, http://amberheardsexsceneob.tumblr.com amber heard sex scene, dehycl, http://terapatricknudeuh.tumblr.com tera patrick nude, 900, http://tilatequilanakedzi.tumblr.com tila tequila naked, =-[,

[Payton_Missouri]

Having said all of that, I wonder if Ande's idea isn't the best (regardless of what format you choose to go with for the blog). If it was still public with no comments, but you cross-posted entries in a private forum, you could allow people to respond and discuss in a controlled/private environment, but still keep the blog itself public. I'm not sure how much extra work that would be for you, but if it was negligible I would say that's the best option for running your site the way you have and seem to love, but keeping the riffraff at bay., http://olgakurylenkohotvh.tumblr.com olga kurylenko hot, 8-OO, http://leamicheletoplessvq.tumblr.com lea michele topless, >:OO, http://patriciaheatonnudefl.tumblr.com patricia heaton nude, 14985, http://katiepriceboobsyy.tumblr.com katie price boobs, 081807, http://christinahendricksbikinihd.tumblr.com christina hendricks bikini, qdubb, http://selenagomeztoplessft.tumblr.com selena gomez topless, :)), http://pinkbikiniot.tumblr.com pink bikini, pvnze, http://virginiamadsennudezz.tumblr.com virginia madsen nude, 214,

[Ava_Arizona]

I do think that by working in a team, it will make it easier for you. The passion moves away from you and to the team of writers, the hate will move with it. Being a part of a groupblog would be a good solution., http://justintimberlakenakedvy.tumblr.com justin timberlake naked, gaokyx, http://lauralinneynudept.tumblr.com laura linney nude, %((, http://camerondiazbikinipg.tumblr.com cameron diaz bikini, =[[, http://marisatomeinakedqi.tumblr.com marisa tomei naked, cdk, http://katewinsletsexscenexj.tumblr.com kate winslet sex scene, 8DD, http://adrianalimasextapete.tumblr.com adriana lima sex tape, sskz, http://vanessahudgenspornks.tumblr.com vanessa hudgens porn, =PPP, http://parishiltonpussyfd.tumblr.com paris hilton pussy, :PPP,

[Ashley_Hawaii]

I think that you'd probably do well in a consulting role where you are helping companies who want to improve in the area of creating passionate users (products and websites). Your knowledge of the field is shown well by your blogging, and maybe getting out in front of people will give you more of a reason to stay passionate about this subject area (if not the blog itself)., http://amandatappinghottv.tumblr.com amanda tapping hot, fwthol, http://staceydashnudejq.tumblr.com stacey dash nude, 412, http://tilatequilasextv.tumblr.com tila tequila sex, =D, http://pamelaandersonnudepicslo.tumblr.com pamela anderson nude pics, ghij, http://rosemcgowannudepf.tumblr.com rose mcgowan nude, :DD, http://kellyosbournenudesq.tumblr.com kelly osbourne nude, 19193, http://parishiltonnudars.tumblr.com paris hilton nuda, 73000, http://hughjackmannudedt.tumblr.com hugh jackman nude, dlag,

[Peyton_Idaho]

O.K. I give up. What is your beef with Gutfeld? I think he is hilarious! He is not a serious contributor, but is there for laughs. I like him., http://vanessaminnillonudewr.tumblr.com vanessa minnillo nude, 8), http://meganfoxpussypq.tumblr.com megan fox pussy, 3643, http://evamendestoplesspc.tumblr.com eva mendes topless, gjschh, http://chynaplayboyop.tumblr.com chyna playboy, 8((, http://kareenakapoorbreastzm.tumblr.com kareena kapoor breast, ugya, http://vanessaminnillonudewr.tumblr.com vanessa minnillo nude, >:-[, http://heathermorrisnudece.tumblr.com heather morris nude, lrqjcg,

[Hannah_Georgia]

I do hesitate to run with the other commenters that say you should monetize this, but you should make it at least a part-time passion where you are getting to stretch out on the things you write about, and then allow experiences to craft other posts., http://kimkardashiannudepicsev.tumblr.com kim kardashian nude pics, lhvtd, http://constancemarienakedlw.tumblr.com constance marie naked, >:), http://mariahcareypornzw.tumblr.com mariah carey porn, 237, http://laurenconradnakedey.tumblr.com lauren conrad naked, :-))), http://bowwownakednx.tumblr.com bow wow naked, bzbq, http://roselynsanchezhotik.tumblr.com roselyn sanchez hot, =PPP, http://sonyawalgernudege.tumblr.com sonya walger nude, 23150, http://amandaseyfriednakedis.tumblr.com amanda seyfried naked, 963,

[Bailey_Georgia]

Kathy, the content you have graciously shared with us every once in a while is both inspiring and entertaining. And a blog is the perfect medium for this. A lot of the content is about your style and creative personality. Thus, I would rule out the community-based ideas. I would probably only read your stuff anyway., http://victoriajusticenudesh.tumblr.com victoria justice nude, 344064, http://leahreminihotib.tumblr.com leah remini hot, 621, http://ditavonteesepornpk.tumblr.com dita von teese porn, 254, http://ginagershonnudedx.tumblr.com gina gershon nude, 58202, http://umathurmannudewt.tumblr.com uma thurman nude, ksq, http://deniserichardsplayboyke.tumblr.com denise richards playboy, 7613, http://mirandakerrnudebo.tumblr.com miranda kerr nude, >:P, http://nehadhupiahotay.tumblr.com neha dhupia hot, lcxn, http://jodiemarshnudejw.tumblr.com jodie marsh nude, >:-(((,

[Autumn_Tennessee]

Use your passion and geek expertise to liberate the latent creativity that resides in readers, something that works better than the linear, sequential and fast fading stream of comments (yeah, this is recursive). Comments are writing, but lets have something not as we know it. Writing in this box just feel a little klunky, there must be a better way, make a better blog :), http://terihatcherhotkx.tumblr.com teri hatcher hot, >:-((, http://carmenelectrapornjj.tumblr.com carmen electra porn, 8(, http://sofiavergaranakedqq.tumblr.com sofia vergara naked, %[[, http://evalongorianakedtd.tumblr.com eva longoria naked, 6801, http://brooklyndeckerhotzn.tumblr.com brooklyn decker hot, 691, http://priyankachoprasexrb.tumblr.com priyanka chopra sex, rjffq, http://emmawatsonnippleslipub.tumblr.com emma watson nipple slip, jtts, http://katiepricesextapect.tumblr.com katie price sex tape, =-OO,

[Gabrielle_Ohio]

Take me for example. I could support Bachman, Cain, Palin, or Santorum. in no particular order. Others would choose fewer plus Paul., http://kristenstewartnudexy.tumblr.com kristen stewart nude, dkrf, http://jessejanepornhd.tumblr.com jesse jane porn, 09840, http://brooklyndeckerhotzn.tumblr.com brooklyn decker hot, evvr, http://kellykellynakedoc.tumblr.com kelly kelly naked, >:PPP, http://lindsaylohanbreastdg.tumblr.com lindsay lohan breast, :-PPP,

[Ella_South_Carolina]

Honestly said, I don't think you can do anything to fend off the attacks. I don't think you got attacked because of something you did, but because lots of people admire you and your work. That's apparently enough for some people to hate you. Only by unpassionating your readers, can you hope to actually stop the haters. I hope you will reject that option., http://ewanmcgregornakedao.tumblr.com ewan mcgregor naked, wlp, http://jenniferconnellysexjh.tumblr.com jennifer connelly sex, 07870, http://shannendohertynudetl.tumblr.com shannen doherty nude, >:-[[, http://carmenelectrasexvideoba.tumblr.com carmen electra sex video, 878, http://scarlettjohanssonhotpk.tumblr.com scarlett johansson hot, oruyj, http://dianelanenudemi.tumblr.com diane lane nude, bpscu, http://scarlettjohanssonbreastpt.tumblr.com scarlett johansson breast, 5015, http://kylieminoguenakedui.tumblr.com kylie minogue naked, >:-]]], http://brooklyndeckerhotzn.tumblr.com brooklyn decker hot, 970,

[Madeline_Louisiana]

That aside, I think that a multiple-contributor blog would give you support and provide some other perspectives. You could combine this with your ideas on coaching/ghostwriting and work with 'intern' contributors to hone their skills, see their work supplying your site, and give them the tools they need to take your philosophies and understanding out on their own tangents. It might give you a regular supply of fresh, new writers and keep things going while allowing you to step back a little. (If you did go with the intern idea, drop me a line, will you? *g*), http://kellykellyplayboytz.tumblr.com kelly kelly playboy, 8932, http://ashleytisdalesextapeht.tumblr.com ashley tisdale sex tape, :-OO, http://salmahayeksexscenexp.tumblr.com salma hayek sex scene, :-DDD, http://pamelaandersonsextapeic.tumblr.com pamela anderson sex tape, vimzz, http://aliciakeysnakedhf.tumblr.com alicia keys naked, >:-), http://milakunisnakedbr.tumblr.com mila kunis naked, %), http://betsyrussellnudeiy.tumblr.com betsy russell nude, %-(, http://zoesaldananakedjt.tumblr.com zoe saldana naked, 676755,

[Naomi_Alabama]

Is there a way use some sort of third party forum moderation to cut through this problem? Then you could go on in whatever way you are comfortable, your forums could coninue to buzz and anyone that's up to no good would hit a brick wall (or get a call from their local authorities, as appropriate). It's just a thought., http://kristindavissexma.tumblr.com kristin davis sex, jyxjv, http://kristinkreuknuderd.tumblr.com kristin kreuk nude, =-D, http://shannontweednakedzq.tumblr.com shannon tweed naked, 550, http://jessicasimpsonbikinizj.tumblr.com jessica simpson bikini, :(((, http://annakournikovanudels.tumblr.com anna kournikova nude, %-PPP, http://keiraknightleynakedwg.tumblr.com keira knightley naked, :))), http://vanessawilliamsnudetg.tumblr.com vanessa williams nude, :]], http://ciarasextapelb.tumblr.com ciara sex tape, >:-OOO, http://kristenstewartsexsceneiy.tumblr.com kristen stewart sex scene, 780,

[Chloe_Texas]

Only reason I voted for him was SARAH. I wasn't even going to vote until he picked her. I had voted in every election since the late 1960?s., http://annafarishotrz.tumblr.com anna faris hot, 523659, http://lindsaylohanpornyq.tumblr.com lindsay lohan porn, brfwsh, http://milakunistoplessbq.tumblr.com mila kunis topless, oepjq, http://janetjacksonnakedwg.tumblr.com janet jackson naked, gqlcmk, http://tilatequilasexvideovy.tumblr.com tila tequila sex video, npzoa, http://priyankachopranudelq.tumblr.com priyanka chopra nude, djxbr, http://meganfoxobenohnevb.tumblr.com megan fox oben ohne, ucujcf, http://jenniferlopezdesnudarl.tumblr.com jennifer lopez desnuda, =D, http://carrieprejeannudebf.tumblr.com carrie prejean nude, 2068,

[Victoria_Oregon]

And a belated Happy Easter to you too! The fruit cakes being compared to bricks definitely makes my chuckle list...perhaps some fruity garnish around the display would have added more relevance. It is quite strange how the human mind works, and association is key to avoid possible misyunderstandings like this one! Classic!, http://ellenpompeonudeck.tumblr.com ellen pompeo nude, mphstx, http://dinameyernudeak.tumblr.com dina meyer nude, 8-]]], http://katherineheiglsexvv.tumblr.com katherine heigl sex, >:), http://rachelmcadamsnakedoi.tumblr.com rachel mcadams naked, xsimmi, http://gwynethpaltrowhotrj.tumblr.com gwyneth paltrow hot, 8-P,

[Trinity_New_Mexico]

I always wondered if the Manchurian Candidate – McLame – would make an appearance. I think he is a victim of Stockholm Syndrome, too., http://kaleycuocosexhe.tumblr.com kaley cuoco sex, 67248, http://selenagomezdesnudagf.tumblr.com selena gomez desnuda, =-[[[, http://jenniferanistonsexscenepw.tumblr.com jennifer aniston sex scene, 189, http://sandrabullocksexymh.tumblr.com sandra bullock sexy, ixl, http://scarlettjohanssonbreastpt.tumblr.com scarlett johansson breast, 953, http://keiraknightleynakedwg.tumblr.com keira knightley naked, 26118, http://emilyosmenthotza.tumblr.com emily osment hot, 8-OO,

[Sophia_New_York]

I do hesitate to run with the other commenters that say you should monetize this, but you should make it at least a part-time passion where you are getting to stretch out on the things you write about, and then allow experiences to craft other posts., http://madonnapornab.tumblr.com madonna porn, lgjt, http://katrinakaifhotbj.tumblr.com katrina kaif hot, :-OOO, http://tarareidpornml.tumblr.com tara reid porn, :O, http://winonarydernuderd.tumblr.com winona ryder nude, 8[[, http://kristenstewartsexsceneiy.tumblr.com kristen stewart sex scene, :PP,

[Leah_New_Jersey]

Use your passion and geek expertise to liberate the latent creativity that resides in readers, something that works better than the linear, sequential and fast fading stream of comments (yeah, this is recursive). Comments are writing, but lets have something not as we know it. Writing in this box just feel a little klunky, there must be a better way, make a better blog :), http://milakunispornrg.tumblr.com mila kunis porn, 0414, http://debbyryannudexr.tumblr.com debby ryan nude, whvmyi, http://evalongoriasexmf.tumblr.com eva longoria sex, bwbwox, http://zacefronnakedit.tumblr.com zac efron naked, lhjh, http://mirandakerrnakedqq.tumblr.com miranda kerr naked, 7812, http://hollyvalancenudelw.tumblr.com holly valance nude, :-]], http://danielradcliffenudeqb.tumblr.com daniel radcliffe nude, 2580,

[Mackenzie_Alabama]

Has he joined Obama in Wonderland where up is down and left is right? What's "fiscally conservative" about voting for every spending measure in sight?, http://angelinajoliesexscenesye.tumblr.com angelina jolie sex scenes, %-PPP, http://www.mazda3club.com/member.php?u=37108 olivia wilde nude, zyr, http://laraduttanudehe.tumblr.com lara dutta nude, bkxuwo, http://vanessahudgenspornks.tumblr.com vanessa hudgens porn, >:], http://chelseahandlerplayboyhe.tumblr.com chelsea handler playboy, 763494, http://jenniferlopezsexvideoxv.tumblr.com jennifer lopez sex video, %D, http://milakunissexsceneit.tumblr.com mila kunis sex scene, 52612, http://jessicaalbasexap.tumblr.com jessica alba sex, prlr, http://annapaquinsexhv.tumblr.com anna paquin sex, 112,

[Bella_Florida]

It makes sense about not continuing with "business as usual" — I couldn't do it, either. But I can't see ghost writing as being satisfiying for someone with as strong a voice as yours. Being an evangelist for the likes of Apple or Adobe might be cool, but would that let you continue with the stream of consciousness riffs that have obviously been satifsying for you — and been so energizing for us, your readers? Don't know., http://lindsaylohanpussyae.tumblr.com lindsay lohan pussy, =-[, http://www.tsf.pt/members/boltavoyuz.aspx olivia wilde nude, >:DD, http://natalieportmandesnudaol.tumblr.com natalie portman desnuda, =-DDD, http://angieharmonnudetx.tumblr.com angie harmon nude, nxg, http://preityzintahotue.tumblr.com preity zinta hot, cec, http://pameladavidplayboyev.tumblr.com pamela david playboy, 8-PPP, http://rachelbilsonnudexh.tumblr.com rachel bilson nude, yarp,

[Olivia_Tennessee]

Kathy, the content you have graciously shared with us every once in a while is both inspiring and entertaining. And a blog is the perfect medium for this. A lot of the content is about your style and creative personality. Thus, I would rule out the community-based ideas. I would probably only read your stuff anyway., http://evagreensexda.tumblr.com eva green sex, ywxq, http://leamichelehotjh.tumblr.com lea michele hot, lfzv, http://katiepricesextapect.tumblr.com katie price sex tape, ncc, http://salmahayekhotaq.tumblr.com salma hayek hot, gwfwe, http://penelopecruzhotvp.tumblr.com penelope cruz hot, imsou, http://trishstratusnudeea.tumblr.com trish stratus nude, ivm, http://natalieportmansexsceneji.tumblr.com natalie portman sex scene, %P, http://naomiwattsnakedqh.tumblr.com naomi watts naked, >:O, http://mariahcareyasszv.tumblr.com mariah carey ass, =-(,

[Lauren_North_Dakota]

That's fine for the House and Senate but for president, there is no way any conservative should vote for either Democrat that will be stuffed down our throats next year. The House is the grand prize. If we had someone like Jim Jordan as Speaker and more than the current 3 reliable conservative senators, the president wouldn't matter., http://masielalushanudeyi.tumblr.com masiela lusha nude, xcnehe, http://christinamiliannakedjh.tumblr.com christina milian naked, 87963, http://ariellekebbelnudenp.tumblr.com arielle kebbel nude, ylkw, http://terapatricksexca.tumblr.com tera patrick sex, 6630, http://aishwaryarainudemk.tumblr.com aishwarya rai nude, 8(((, http://leeanntweedennudeft.tumblr.com leeann tweeden nude, :P, http://shakirabikinieu.tumblr.com shakira bikini, :(,

[Riley_Hawaii]

Good for Hannity, hammering Mc Cain. Mc Cain off as so slimey. He completely bought into the Obama narrative and talks about the great calamity to come if there is no agreement, and continues to blast the Tea Party., http://aliceevenudeau.tumblr.com alice eve nude, %[, http://parishiltonfuckingkz.tumblr.com paris hilton fucking, 2464, http://robintunneynudejc.tumblr.com robin tunney nude, >:]], http://saraunderwoodnakedul.tumblr.com sara underwood naked, 254, http://marioncotillardnudekf.tumblr.com marion cotillard nude, nflt, http://kristenbellsexeb.tumblr.com kristen bell sex, %-]]], http://maggieqsextapehn.tumblr.com maggie q sex tape, vhq, http://winonarydernuderd.tumblr.com winona ryder nude, dxv, http://vanessahudgensnudephotosll.tumblr.com vanessa hudgens nude photos, 54954,

[Charlotte_Illinois]

I do think that by working in a team, it will make it easier for you. The passion moves away from you and to the team of writers, the hate will move with it. Being a part of a groupblog would be a good solution., http://halleberrynakedhz.tumblr.com halle berry naked, %-O, http://pamelaandersontoplesslm.tumblr.com pamela anderson topless, hxgwjc, http://kaleycuoconakedvu.tumblr.com kaley cuoco naked, :-DD, http://christinaaguileranudepicszg.tumblr.com christina aguilera nude pics, =(((, http://katrinakaifsexrc.tumblr.com katrina kaif sex, sblpyd, http://emmawatsonslipey.tumblr.com emma watson slip, bzi, http://parishiltonfuckingkz.tumblr.com paris hilton fucking, >:-(((,

[Gabrielle_Vermont]

I see two basic options for you: Reduce visibility and do something completely different, or stay visible and continue publishing your own stuff under your own name. All the options you cite can be assigned to one of these two categories. I dearly hope you go with the second option, even though I would totally understand if you decide otherwise., http://bowwownakednx.tumblr.com bow wow naked, :), http://katewinsletpornxk.tumblr.com kate winslet porn, %-(((, http://jessicabielpornxm.tumblr.com jessica biel porn, 978317, http://tealeonihottu.tumblr.com tea leoni hot, 59553, http://mauratierneynudend.tumblr.com maura tierney nude, 7145, http://christinahendrickssexpy.tumblr.com christina hendricks sex, 1456, http://kathygriffinnudevf.tumblr.com kathy griffin nude, 174,